A StreetEasy report finds that New York City buyers purchasing a median-priced apartment at $900,000 now take nearly 15 years to break even against renters, up two years from 2025. Tight inventory drives the gap. Rental stock fell 15.2 percent in the last year, while Manhattan's median asking rent rose 8.6 percent citywide to $4,120 monthly by spring. In October, 21 percent of NYC homes sold above asking.
A few neighborhoods buck the trend. In Brooklyn Heights, the median sales price of $870,000 against annual asking rent of $5,150 means buyers break even in 6.8 years. Gramercy Park shows similar math: a $962,000 median sales price and $5,500 median rental yield a 7.2-year break-even. The report notes single-family conversions have thinned rental supply in Brooklyn Heights.
Queens and the Bronx offer faster payoffs for buyers. Rego Park and Oakland Gardens in Queens plus Riverdale in the Bronx each have a median sales price of $400,000 against a $3,275 monthly median rent, bringing break-even to 3.9 years.
The report assumes buyers need at least ten years in a home to profit after closing costs and broker fees justify the purchase over renting.