The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals will decide whether to keep FinCEN's Residential Real Estate Rule off the books. The rule, which was vacated in late March by a federal judge in the Eastern District of Texas after less than three weeks in effect, required reporting for any non-financed residential real estate transfer held by an entity or trust with no geographic or price threshold.

FinCEN appealed the ruling in early May. In late October, the American Land Title Association (ALTA) and Texas Land Title Association (TLTA) filed amicus briefs urging the Fifth Circuit to uphold the original decision to vacate the rule.

ALTA and TLTA argue the rule "imposes significant costs and operational burdens on title and settlement professionals without adequately demonstrating that its benefits justify those requirements." ALTA states FinCEN's cost estimate of $559.4 million is too low because it failed to account for employee training, technology changes, record keeping, and time spent gathering information from buyers and sellers. Title professionals lack authority to compel beneficial ownership information from buyers or sellers, ALTA adds, and financial institutions already collect this data when accounts open.

TLTA contends that transactions the rule targets are routine and legal, and that FinCEN's authority only extends to "suspicious" transactions, not an entire class of transaction.

The lawsuit originated with Flowers Title Companies, LLC, which argued FinCEN lacked authority under the Bank Secrecy Act to impose such requirements.

FinCEN stated it will not require retroactive reporting for transactions during these legal proceedings. The agency maintained the rule was necessary to close loopholes allowing money launderers, drug traffickers, and illicit actors to use shell companies and trusts to purchase property anonymously.

Fidelity National Financial challenged the rule in a separate case that resulted in the rule being upheld. FNF has since appealed that decision in the Eleventh Circuit.