Neil Heuer, a semi-retired tech entrepreneur living in Aero Plantation, an exclusive fly-in community in Waxhaw, NC, faces an HOA dispute over his annual Christmas and Halloween light displays featuring more than 60,000 lights, choreographed animatronic displays, and music programming. Heuer has spent more than $70,000 on the exhibitions over five years.

The HOA's legal counsel, Benjamin Karb, wrote in an August letter that the displays invite unknown members of the public into the private subdivision, calling it "the type of offensive activity that is a nuisance or annoyance to the neighborhood" and violating the HOA's Declaration. Heuer counters that 90 percent of cars passing his home belong to non-neighbors anyway. He argues the real issue stems from a golf course dispute and his anonymous newsletter criticizing the HOA.

In a September 2026 hearing, the HOA alleged violations of exterior lighting, signage size, traffic, guest limits, and architectural alterations rules. The board found no violation regarding visitor traffic but cited violations on lighting and signage. A sign Heuer erected to inform visitors that off-duty sheriff's deputies patrolling the area had been hired by the HOA was found to violate signage limits.

Heuer filed a lawsuit in Union Superior Court in early October alleging the HOA overstepped its authority and failed to provide proper notice. He claims restrictions had never been formally adopted in the bylaws. The case is ongoing.

The HOA board adopted new parking rules holding owners directly responsible for any traffic or parking resulting from activities that attract nonresident traffic on private roads. Two proposed bylaw amendments would establish standards for public attractions generating nonresident traffic and standards for flashing, strobing, and high-intensity exterior lighting. The vote is scheduled for the end of January.

Heuer plans to run his holiday display again this year before the new rules take effect. HOA President David Arno told Realtor.com that the Association will respond to the lawsuit through the appropriate legal process.