After years of turmoil and failed deals, The Lincoln at 1601 Washington Avenue appears poised for a fresh start. Alfred Equities, led by Abraham B. Schwartz, is under contract to purchase the former Starwood Capital Group headquarters for $55.8 million—a price that, while substantial, represents a significant markdown from the building's troubled history. For a 131,220-square-foot, eight-story asset that once commanded $80 million and $82 million valuations, the current offer signals just how much damage prolonged uncertainty can inflict on Miami Beach commercial real estate.

The building's descent reads like a cautionary tale. When Elie Schwartz's Nightingale Properties acquired the ground lease in 2016 for $80 million through a crowdfunding platform, the asset seemed positioned for success. But Schwartz's subsequent conviction on fraud charges—he was sentenced to seven years in federal prison for misappropriating investor funds—cast a shadow that never fully lifted. By 2023, when Robert Rivani's Black Lion went under contract at $82 million, the damage was already done. That deal collapsed, and the property eventually fell under lender control after Granite Point Mortgage Trust released an $84.7 million loan through a deed in lieu of foreclosure.

What makes Alfred Equities' bid noteworthy is not just the price, but the structure. The New York-based firm will co-own the asset with family trusts tied to Aryeh and Rivka May, plus several limited partners. This shared ownership model suggests confidence in the building's fundamentals—the 106,652 square feet of office space, 28,483 square feet of retail, and 493-space parking garage remain valuable. The challenge now is execution and finding tenants willing to look past The Lincoln's troubled history.

The timing is crucial. On November 18, Miami Beach's commission must waive its right of first refusal on the ground lease to allow the deal to close. This procedural step should not be taken for granted, but given the city's interest in moving troubled assets off lenders' books, approval seems likely. The property sits on a 1.4-acre site owned by the City of Miami Beach itself—a reminder that this transaction involves public interests alongside private ones.

Alfred Equities' acquisition reflects a broader trend in Miami Beach, where wealthy executives increasingly seek office space near their homes. Todd Rosenberg's Pebb Capital paid over $70 million for the Uno building this summer, while Rivani snapped up a neighboring 156,752-square-foot asset for $31.5 million. If The Lincoln can shed its reputational baggage and compete effectively in this market, it might finally become the asset its bones suggest it could be.