Dena Bergamasco, a first-time homebuyer, sued Howard Hanna Real Estate Services this month over a $395 "Realtor Transaction Fee" she says she was forced to pay on top of her buyer broker commission when she purchased a home in October 2021.

Bergamasco's attorneys claim Howard Hanna breached its fiduciary duty and violated Florida's Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law by charging the fee for "nothing" with "no service behind it, no cost behind it, and no name that accurately describes it." The complaint states the fee appeared on her closing disclosure wedged between a pest inspection charge and an owner's title insurance premium.

According to the filing, Bergamasco paid $217,000 for her home using a $213,069 federally insured mortgage, a $10,850 second loan from the Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency, and a $7,300 seller credit toward closing costs. She brought $788.95 in cash to closing, less than double the alleged fee.

The complaint alleges that Howard Hanna coaches agents to tell clients the fee is mandatory and serves a "processing" or "administrative" purpose. Bergamasco's attorneys note that because the transaction occurred before the Sitzer/Burnett commission lawsuit settlement, the buyer broker commission was paid by the home seller, and Bergamasco separately paid the settlement agent and title insurance provider for their services.

The suit seeks class action status and damages, plus a permanent injunction against Howard Hanna charging the fee in the future. Bergamasco is represented by Kopelowitz Ostrow P.A., which also represents a plaintiff in a similar lawsuit against a Keller Williams franchise over a $650 "broker fee."

Compass faced a since-dismissed lawsuit over an alleged $475 transaction fee. The Consumer Policy Center reports consumers pay up to $2 billion annually in brokerage transaction fees.