Compass International Holdings is seeking to move an antitrust lawsuit out of federal court in New York, where eight multiple listing services have sued together over MLS cooperation and listing submission rules.
The eight MLSs—Arizona Regional MLS, OneKey MLS, MLSListings, Bridge MLS, Canopy MLS, Recolorado, Hive MLS, and Doorify MLS—filed their consolidated case in the Southern District of New York after Compass sent demand letters in September telling MLSs nationwide to stop fining agents for publicly marketing office exclusive listings.
In a Nov. 13 letter, Compass asked the judge to dismiss the case or split it into eight separate cases in the federal districts where Compass has filed its own antitrust claims against each MLS. Arizona, Northern California, Colorado, and the Western and Eastern Districts of North Carolina would each handle one MLS's claims under this proposal.
Compass called the consolidated suit "improper anticipatory filing" under the Declaratory Judgment Act. The company argued the MLSs requested extensions to respond to its demands, then sued in New York the day after certain deadlines expired. Compass said the MLSs operate independently in distinct regional markets with different boards and rules, so consolidating them in one court creates inefficiency.
The MLSs countered on Wednesday that consolidation is proper. They said Compass orchestrated a "nationwide campaign" from its New York headquarters against their cooperation rules and should face a single forum. The MLSs noted that Compass sued Zillow over cooperation rules in the same New York court, and that Compass's strategy of filing 15 cases across 11 districts invites inconsistent outcomes.
The MLSs also disputed Compass's characterization of pre-suit negotiations. They said Compass offered only two options: abandon their rules entirely for a "toothless" release that left them under "perpetual threat" of future litigation, or face lawsuits without clarity on timing or venue.
The court's ruling on where the case proceeds will determine how federal courts address the legality of MLS rules requiring brokers to share publicly marketed listings through the MLS cooperative database.