Compass International Holdings filed a motion on Tuesday seeking to dismiss an antitrust lawsuit that accuses it of creating a monopoly through acquisitions and harming consumers by pulling its rental listings from StreetEasy in early August.

The lawsuit, filed in late August, claims Compass's removal reduced consumer choice, drove up rents, and increased brokerage fees. In its dismissal filing, Compass argues the plaintiffs confused the residential sales market with the rental market. The company says the complaint cites data about for-sale homes, not rentals.

Compass claims it does not own rental properties, set rental prices, or hold monopoly power in the rental listings market. It points to Zillow and StreetEasy as the dominant platforms in online listing searches. Compass also states the plaintiff cannot prove its conduct caused higher rent.

The company attributes the decline in visible rental inventory to New York City's June 2025 Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses (FARE) Act, which prohibits brokers hired by landlords from charging tenant fees and requires fee disclosure before lease signing. Compass notes rental inventory in New York City began declining seven months before its Anywhere acquisition and over a year before it instructed agents to pull listings from StreetEasy.

Compass argues it has no legal obligation to share listings with platforms like StreetEasy. The company also requested the court stay discovery while the motion to dismiss is pending. The court has not ruled on that request. The plaintiff has until December 8, 2026, to respond to Compass's motion.