Sam Fetters and his wife faced day-care costs of $2,200 per month for their daughter in Brooklyn, more than their rent-stabilized rent in Ditmas Park. His father proposed an alternative: they would rent him an apartment in the city, and he and his wife would provide full-time child care instead.
The couple found a $2,000-a-month one-bedroom in Prospect Heights on St. Marks Avenue. Rob and Susan Fetters moved in and split child-care duties into morning and afternoon shifts to avoid spending all day together in the small space. They played with their granddaughter Margot, took her to Prospect Park and the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, cooked meals, and tidied up at their son's apartment. The arrangement lasted several years and allowed the family to avoid day-care expenses.
A similar setup worked for Anne McPherson, who set up her mother-in-law Sheila in a roughly $3,250-a-month studio in downtown Brooklyn while she returned to her communications job. Sheila took their son Langston to music classes and parks. After six months, Sheila returned to Jamaica, missing her husband and friends. Langston then entered day care.
A tech marketer said her mother-in-law moved to the city temporarily in 2021 and watched her son, allowing the couple to try for a second child earlier than planned. After three years, the mother-in-law left because caring for two children was physically taxing and the older child kept bringing home germs. The couple paid roughly a third of what their current full-time nanny costs, the mother said.
A marketing professional in midtown Manhattan had her mother move from suburban Philadelphia nearly a decade ago to help care for one child. The arrangement became permanent. The grandmother now watches three children after school and on specific days. The mother claims two mortgages remain more economical than child care for three kids.
Child-care costs in New York City reached as much as $26,000 per year in 2024, according to a comptroller's report. Costs have jumped at least $4,000 since 2019. Families using full-time nannies pay double or nearly triple that amount.