Lamacchia Realty and eight of its agents sued Chinatti Realty Group in Massachusetts Superior Court over what they claim are excessive referral fees charged when agents who left Chinatti close deals involving leads from Chinatti's database.

The lawsuit, filed in August 2024 and amended in February 2025, alleges that Chinatti Realty Group charged referral fees as high as 85% on transactions closed by former employees. Lamacchia Realty said it has paid Chinatti Realty Group more than $350,000 in 75% to 85% referral fees on behalf of the departing agents.

The plaintiffs also claim they were not paid commissions on transactions that were pending when they left Chinatti for Lamacchia. Lamacchia Realty said it paid the agents $113,443 to cover commissions they did not receive from Chinatti for deals that closed after departure.

The agents allege Chinatti misclassified them as independent contractors despite exercising controls beyond normal broker supervision. They claim Chinatti's independent contractor agreements were unconscionable.

Judge Lynn Rooney ruled in September that Chinatti intentionally destroyed relevant data when she switched from Real Geeks CRM to Zillow's Follow Up Boss in December 2024. Rooney found that Chinatti knew the information was relevant to the dispute since she received a demand letter from Lamacchia in November 2022, yet took no steps to preserve the Real Geeks records. The judge said at trial, the jury must receive "very clear and forceful instruction" that missing evidence would have been unfavorable to the defendants.

The court also discovered that agents' CRM activity and phone conversations were monitored and recorded without the participants' permission. Judge Rooney forwarded the ruling and these concerns to the Massachusetts Attorney General's Criminal Bureau for review of potential wiretap violations.

The plaintiffs filed a motion this month requesting denial of summary judgement motions filed by defendants and asking the court to schedule a final pretrial conference. The court has not yet ruled on that motion or Chinatti's summary judgement motions.

Chinatti did not respond to requests for comment.